Thursday, 24 March 2016

What is 'Digital Wellbeing'?

This is the first of a few posts on digital wellbeing. The term is one I coined - or at least brought into the education space - while I was working on a new Digital Capabillities framework for UK HE and FE (funded by Jisc) in 2015. Here, from the framework, is my definition.

To care for our 'digital wellbeing' is to:
  • look after personal health, safety, relationships and work-life balance in digital settings; 
  • act safely and responsibly in digital environments; 
  • manage digital stress, workload and distraction; 
  • use digital media to participate in political and community actions;
  • use personal digital data for wellbeing benefits;
  • act with concern for the human and natural environment when using digital tools; 
  • balance digital with real-world interactions appropriately in relationships;
  • ...
There are diverse issues here, and more could be added. What links them is an understanding that digital technology saturates our lives, including our embodied lives. Our digital and physical identities are constantly passing into one another through the devices we carry, the data we shed, and the representations we capture and share. Our bodies and brains, our knowledge of self and world, our working lives and our personal relationships are all radically transformed in this process. (Different subject areas have different ways of framing these transformations, and the responsibilities of educators surely include exploring what each knowledge / practice area adds to our understanding of the digital revolution and outlining what kinds of knowledgeable/capable selves can develop within that subject space.)

It was challenging to insert wellbeing into a framework of individual capabilities, especially as I don't think being well is only or mainly an individual responsibility. The design of learning systems, the contents of digital curricula, the distribution of digital know-how, the business models of digital development, the globalisation of digital labour... these are issues with profound impact on our capacity to thrive, over which no individual has  control. But I think it's useful, and potentially radical, to suggest that digital capability includes self-care, and that self-care requires a critical awareness of how digital technologies act on us and sometimes against us, as well as allowing us to pursue our personal and collective aspirations in new ways.

In using the terms 'capbility' and 'wellbeing' in a digital space I am consciously drawing on Martha Nussbaum's work on human development. Too rich to summarise here, her ideas are opened out nicely from an online review of her 2011 book Creating Capabilities: the human development approach.

My own work on the experiences of digital students had already led me to question what it means to thrive in a learning environment that is saturated with digital technologies. Students have many concerns about the impact of digital technology on their wellbeing, if we listen. This goes back to my original definition of digital literacy for Jisc (2010):
those capabilities that enable an individual to thrive (live, learn and work) in a digital society.

In 2015 I was also conducting interviews with a wide range of staff, and considering the future of work both inside and outside education. I summarised these findings in my report Deepening Digital Knowhow: Building Digital Talent (first two sections) and in much more detail in Employability and the Future of Digital Work, part of a symposium for the Networked Learning Conference 2016.

Since delivering the framework, blogging about it on the Jisc site, and producing this podcast, I have had a positive reaction from different sectors and from different parts of the world. For example:

1. I presented keynotes on digital wellbeing at the UCISA Spotlight on Digital Capability event and at EdTech15 in Galway, and at a range of events since then (see my slideshare account). An #LTHEchat about the subject resulted in this re-drawing of Maslow's hierarchy of needs by Simon Rae (thank you Simon).

@simonrae


The link with Maslow is a reminder that digitally-mediated learning still happens between human beings with human needs for safety, nurture and care, for a sense of belonging and for personal attention. Other writers such as Laura Czerniewicz, Catherine Cronin and Gardner Campbell are raising the question of what love and care for learners might look like in digital settings.

2. 'Digital identity and wellbeing' was included prominently in the Irish National Forum's new (2015) framework of digital skills for HE, after conversations between myself and Jim Devine. You can see  the final frameworks on pp. 35 and 36 of this report.
(c) allaboardhe.org

Elsewhere in the report there is a useful account of how conceptions of digital literacy have evolved in the UK and Ireland, with evidence of how widely used are the digital literacy development pyramid (myself and Rhona Sharpe, 2009), the Jisc definition of digital literacies (myself and Allison Littlejohn and Lou McGill, 2010) and the two frameworks I developed for Jisc in 2010 and 2015.

3. 'Digital wellbeing' is a theme for the 2016 Designs on e-Learning conference in New York City, with the call for papers using a definition that closely follows mine in the Jisc framework. I like the connection between 'design' and wellbeing, because the two have often been antithetical in accounts of how people learn.  'Learning design' has tended to treat learners as rational users of a rational system or - worse - as components of the system to be known through measurement and tracking. Here they are treated as embodied, socially-connected and potentially vulnerable human beings, whose learning involves investment and risk as well as cognitive effort.

http://www.designsonelearning.net/call-for-papers/

4. I was invited to talk about the framework with universities across Australia, which has led to the formation of a community of practice in digital capability development. Digital wellbeing was the area that elicited the most interest and excitement over there. The term 'wellbeing' resonates immediately with professional staff - librarians, careers advisers, learning skills professionals and other student-facing specialists - who support learners in ways that are not directly concerned with their subject knowledge or assessments. But teaching in its traditional sense also involves care: acknowledgement of everything learners bring to the experience of learning, including their motivations, challenges, and prior experiences, and an interest in their specific paths of development.

5. I was invited to contribute to a European framework on developing Digitally Capable Organisations which is being further developed into tools for use in schools. I have more recently been invited to contribute to a Commonwealth of Learning framework on Digital Education Leadership (forthcoming 2016). In both cases I think my contribution is to stress the responsibility that educational organisations have for the wellbeing of all staff and learners as they rely more on digital systems and introduce more digitally-based practices.

6. I've also been approached by health education bodies to consider developing a common framework. The wellbeing aspect of the Jisc framework is particularly appealing to this sector.

7. I've been approached to work collaboratively with specialists in e-safety and cyberbullying, who feel that 'digital wellbeing' is a particularly helpful term to use in post-compulsory education. Adult learners may not see themselves as needing support to be 'safe' or 'respectful' online, despite the fact that cyberbullying is an increasing problem in universities. But they are interested in how to live, learn and work effectively in digital spaces - for example to understand different norms and cultures of online expression. They also have legitimate concerns about how living, learning and working relationships play out differently in those spaces.

One of the joys of working and publishing openly in a digital community is to watch ideas taken up in diverse ways, taking on their own lives and meaning different things to different people. As I've argued elsewhere, terms such as 'digital wellbeing', 'digital literacy' or 'digital capability', are useful only if they allow new conversations to happen, and ultimately if they usher in new forms of practice or critique. They belong to whoever can make use of them, and once they are no longer useful they fall away (though if they have had any traction, they leave changes behind them).

For me the important thing is for there to be an open dialogue, recognising that ideas have a history and provenance, and that their contexts of production and sharing deserve some attention.

Thanks for bearing with me. In further posts I'll look at different aspects of digital wellbeing, depending on interest.

44 comments:

Frances Bell said...

Really looking forward to chatting with you about this when we meet. Some recent work I am doing with others brings a different dimension to bullet point 4 :)

HelenB said...

That would be great Frances. I'm just putting in some references to Martha Nussbaum's work here...

Unknown said...

Hi Helen and Frances

I've bene doing a little bit of work around trying to put some of these ideas into practice with our team in the first instance. It'll be good to swap notes soon :)

Suzanne

Iain MacLaren said...

Great summary, Helen and as you pointed out the idea has been enthusiastically embraced by those of us involved in Ireland's national project: "All Aboard! Empowering and enabling staff and students to flourish in the digital age." After conversations with you on your work with JISC we felt that the term 'wellbeing' better articulated so many of the concepts and ideas that are (increasingly?) important in how we negotiate the digital world not just in terms of our own selves but the manner in which we interact with each other. Our original draft talked about 'digital citizenship' but wellbeing has so much more power, breadth and depth. Thank you, once again, for inspiring our work.

Iain

Nikos Palavitsinis said...

Mind-blown... Really really interesting article! Thanks so much! May borrow and reference various parts in a blog post...!

Sheila MacNeill said...

Great post Helen, thank you for sharing.

Herry jonson said...

Ekkomedia master in data innovation and web. We are managing web design company, web advancement organization, photography organization, and film creation organization, film altering organization and online networking advertising.

Mark Williams said...

Great post. I'm looking to research this area for my MA Creative Ed. and I've just got myself a copy of the Nussbaum book too.

Sara Loren said...

This blog Info is fabulous; I must wanna see best more from your writers.

benefits of learning a second language

Jaya Pratha said...


very nice blogs!!! i have to learning for lot of information for this sites...Sharing for wonderful information.Thanks for sharing this valuable information to our vision. You have posted a trust worthy blog keep sharing.
Bangalore Web Design Companies

Jr. Williams said...

Free online college courses?
Educational courses

Sathiaja Sarah said...

dear,
website author
Ever seen one of those advertisements stating that you can get a website designed for some ridiculous low sum of money? How much should you pay for a decent web design?
To learn more about it see:website design Massachusetts

Sathiaja Sarah said...




dear,
friends
There are many key points to remember when making the right choice for your Branson web designer. These apply to all businesses who are currently seeking a web designer for their new project.
see more details:website design Massachusetts

Sathiaja Sarah said...


dear,
friends
There are many key points to remember when making the right choice for your Branson web designer. These apply to all businesses who are currently seeking a web designer for their new project.
see more details:web design Massachusetts



cap vision said...

nice post Web design

Sathiaja Sarah said...

dear,
friends
There are many key points to remember when making the right choice for your Branson web designer. These apply to all businesses who are currently seeking a web designer for their new project.
see more details:web design Massachusetts

GateIIT Coaching said...

gate biotechnology coaching centres
gate coaching for chemical engineering
gate coaching for civil engineering
ies coaching centers
iit jee coaching institutes
gate coaching for aerospace engineering

Amber minds said...

Great post , thanks for sharing with us...!
web designing bangalore

A.S.M. Jibon said...

Good article, well organized, easy to navigate and provides useful insights. Thank you for sharing. How can I vote for your site/post? Have you polling system for your articles like Leaderpoll ? Will you give a chance to vote this post by adding polling system?
Thanks once again for the great tips.

williamson said...

Hi

Global Incorporate involves researched and knowledgeable infromation which enhaces the facts of Digital Marketing. It highlights on the key aspects of the Digital World together with SEO and Social Media Strategies.

Harrison Reynolds said...

your article about digital wellbeing is perfevt to all it.s followeres. Houston web Design Company

victoria eden said...

Thanks so much for sharing. I got relavant information from your post.
Melbourne Web Designer

Gary White said...

Looking for preparation courses for GAMSAT in Perth Australia?

GAMSAT Practice Questions

Mark smith said...

Super blog and very interesting information which I always wanted to search many article but you article is really fantastic.
meaning of palaeontology

Zinavo Technologies said...

Its very good informative blog, it's very useful. Thanks for sharing. Website Design Company Bangalore | Web Development Company Bangalore

Rebs said...

All too often we have only a vague sense of our development areas and no clue as to how to address development Areas In work, areas of development.The purpose of the leadership development centre therefore was to provide detailed evidence-based and externally benchmarked information about an individual’s strengths and weaknesses.

umer said...

Very interesting and informative blog and about the Learn programming and I must appreciate your work well done keep it up.
Learn programming

Bangalore Web Guru said...

Extremely fascinating and instructive blog and about the Learn programming and I should value your function admirably done keep it up.

Website Design Companies Bangalore |
Web Design Services Bangalore

Unknown said...

EasyShiksha is the best education blog that keep you so much forward than others.

Thamizharasi J said...

i think this is right way of information to start student career to get the bright future. i really happy for this kind of article and wish to go more level of shares for us. thanks well and keep doing more things.
PTE Coaching in Chennai

Hristo Yanev said...

Hi fellas,
Thank you so much for this wonderful article really!
If someone want to read more about that GAMSAT Practice Test I think this is the right place for you!

W3 Dream said...

Nice! I have enjoyed reading your post. It is well written. It looks like you spend a large amount of time and effort in writing the blog. I am appreciating your effort. You can visit my site.
Website designers in bangalore | Website designers in bangalore freelancers

lemon said...



Hi admin,

I read your blog, Its really awesome, I have also a blog which is related with you, which is aboutwebsite design Massachusetts.
Nowadays, staying competitive involves more than just having a website - retailers need to maximize their web presence.
This involves a combined effort of leveraging your website,
website design Massachusetts

Thanks,

lemon


Prasanth said...

Thanks for the information. Helped us to convince most on how this process works and what they could achieve by following these guidelines.
UI Designing Company in Bangalore, Web Application Development Companies in Bangalore

Emran Hossen said...

Thanks for sharing as it is an excellent post Webdesign Nürnberg

Emran Hossen said...

Thanks for sharing as it is an excellent post Webdesign Nürnberg

md kawsir said...

digital Bangladesh

Dipika Takali said...

Hello, Helen
Thanks for sharing about digital wellbeing, very informative post. Keep sharing your informative post with us
Web Design Company in Bangalore | web Development Company in Bangalore | Website Design Company in Bangalore

Subarna said...


I found some useful information in your blog, it was awesome to read, thank you for sharing this great content, keep sharing..

web developer austin
austin web design

Blogging Workshpp said...

Thank you for sharing such a nice and interesting blog with us.very unique and recommanded I would like to suggest your blog

in my frnd circle.learn blogging

victoria eden said...

I like your blog a lot. Its informative and full of information. Thank you for sharing.
Melbourne Web Designer

free business listing said...

free business listing sites usa
website design company in usa
website design company in Hyderabad
website design company in Delhi
website design company in Vijayawada
website design company in Mumbai
free classified site list usa

rakesh said...

Nice Article
website design in bangalore
Ecommerce website design in bangalore
digital marketing company in bangalore

webwing said...

If you are finding best graphic design companies then we are best graphic design companies in united kingdom and we provide customer goods